The Global Home for CinemaEst. 2026
Film Village
Casting

Lili Reinhart in Talks to Star in Polly Pocket Movie After Lily Collins Steps Away

Lili Reinhart is in talks to lead and executive produce Amazon MGM and Mattel Studios' Polly Pocket, with Clea DuVall directing.

Lili Reinhart

Village people, we have casting news from a very small world! Lili Reinhart is in discussions to star in, and executive produce, Polly Pocket for Amazon MGM and Mattel Studios. Nothing is locked in yet, so we are keeping our fingers crossed and our tiny compacts closed.

Reinhart would step into the lead role after Lily Collins left the project because of scheduling issues. The good news is that Collins is staying on board as an executive producer, so she remains part of the family.

The Team Behind the Toy

Clea DuVall is directing, working from a screenplay by Dan Brier and Jordan Weiss. Robbie Brenner produces for Mattel Studios, alongside Reese Witherspoon and Lauren Neustadter for Hello Sunshine. Executive producers include Mattel Studios and Hello Sunshine’s Emily Ferenbach, Jeff Waxman and Jennifer Madeloff. The film is headed to Prime Video.

Reinhart is best known as Betty Cooper in Riverdale and recently led the Prime Video rom-com The Love Hypothesis. Her big-screen credits also include Forbidden Fruits, American Sweatshop and Look Both Ways.

Mattel’s Movie Moment

Ever since Barbie took the world by storm in 2023, Mattel has been charging into cinema. 2026 saw Masters of the Universe reach theatres in June and Matchbox land on Apple TV in October. Still to come are Barney with Ayo Edebiri, Hot Wheels from producer J.J. Abrams and director Jon M. Chu, and Rock ‘Em Sock ‘Em Robots, written by and starring Vin Diesel.

Polly Pocket first arrived on shelves in the summer of 1989 through Bluebird Toys. Mattel picked up the brand in 1998 and gave it a fresh, modern look in 2018 for a new generation of kids.

I’m usually found deep in a noir fog or a French New Wave rabbit hole, but I’ll happily admit there’s something magic about a whole world folded into a pocket-sized shell. It’s a great hook for a movie.

So what do you think, Village? Is Reinhart the right fit to shrink down for Polly? Head to the message board and tell us who you’d love to see in the supporting cast.

Original reporting
Variety
Talk about it in the Village Join the conversation