The Biggest Film Debates Right Now
Director's cuts, subtitles, phones in cinemas and the never-ending Bond question. Pick a side.
Every pub I’ve ever drunk in has had one bloke who’ll argue about films until they turn the lights on. I am that bloke. So this is my favourite page on the whole site.
1. Is the director’s cut ever actually better?
Sometimes, yes. Sometimes it’s just longer. My dad swears blind the theatrical cut of a certain science fiction classic is the one, voiceover and all, and we have not spoken about it calmly since 2007.
2. Subtitles or dubs?
Subtitles. Next question. Actually, no, fair play, some people watch with the kids or while cooking. But if you’re watching Jill’s French New Wave recommendations dubbed, she will find you.
3. Phones in the cinema
Lock them in a little pouch at the door. I’ll die on this hill.
4. Is Robert Pattinson the right Bond?
Well, we have our answer now: Robert Pattinson is the new 007. This was way before my time, but my dad tells me when they cast Roger Moore half the country said he was too posh and the other half said he was too old. Same uproar, every single time. And every single time, we end up loving whoever it is.
That’s four. You’ve got more. Bring them to the Village and let’s have it out, nicely.

